NaNDA Corridor Summary

This summary page groups the shortlisted cities into large, mid, and small population bands and pulls together the corridor-level NaNDA outputs already generated for each city. Each city card is labeled by its parking-reform role so the visual comparisons stay tied to the treatment design.

The category sections embed the exported time-series and delta charts directly. Where available, the linked delta maps open the tract choropleths with corridor overlays. A normalized citywide-baseline graphic currently exists only where that rerun has been completed.

Full removal Partial / limited removal Proposal only

Large Cities

5 shortlisted cities.

San Francisco

California · Large group

Full Removal 2018-12-11
Eating / Drinking

Top eating / drinking corridor change: Mission Street (+126.7).

San Francisco Eating / Drinking time series
Eating / Drinking corridor time series.
San Francisco Eating / Drinking delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Retail

Top retail corridor change: Haight Street (+4.2).

San Francisco Retail time series
Retail corridor time series.
San Francisco Retail delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Grocery

Top grocery corridor change: 3rd Street (-0.1).

San Francisco Grocery time series
Grocery corridor time series.
San Francisco Grocery delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience

Top liquor / tobacco / convenience corridor change: Union Street (+4.0).

San Francisco Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience time series
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience corridor time series.
San Francisco Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Personal Care / Laundromats

Top personal care / laundromats corridor change: Mission Street (+17.8).

San Francisco Personal Care / Laundromats time series
Personal Care / Laundromats corridor time series.
San Francisco Personal Care / Laundromats delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Recreation

Top recreation corridor change: 24th Street (+0.0).

San Francisco Recreation time series
Recreation corridor time series.
San Francisco Recreation delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Dollar Stores

Top dollar stores corridor change: 24th Street (+0.0).

San Francisco Dollar Stores time series
Dollar Stores corridor time series.
San Francisco Dollar Stores delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.

San Jose

California · Large group

Full Removal 2022-12-06
Eating / Drinking

Top eating / drinking corridor change: Santa Clara Street (+16.6).

San Jose Eating / Drinking time series
Eating / Drinking corridor time series.
San Jose Eating / Drinking delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Retail

Top retail corridor change: Stevens Creek Boulevard (+2.4).

San Jose Retail time series
Retail corridor time series.
San Jose Retail delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Grocery

Top grocery corridor change: Monterey Road (+1.2).

San Jose Grocery time series
Grocery corridor time series.
San Jose Grocery delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience

Top liquor / tobacco / convenience corridor change: Capitol Expressway (+1.7).

San Jose Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience time series
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience corridor time series.
San Jose Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Personal Care / Laundromats

Top personal care / laundromats corridor change: Monterey Road (+4.7).

San Jose Personal Care / Laundromats time series
Personal Care / Laundromats corridor time series.
San Jose Personal Care / Laundromats delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Recreation

Top recreation corridor change: Alum Rock Avenue (+0.0).

San Jose Recreation time series
Recreation corridor time series.
San Jose Recreation delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Dollar Stores

Top dollar stores corridor change: Blossom Hill Road (+0.2).

San Jose Dollar Stores time series
Dollar Stores corridor time series.
San Jose Dollar Stores delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.

Seattle

Washington · Large group

Partial / Limited Removal Date not pinned in local citywide file
Eating / Drinking

Top eating / drinking corridor change: Pike Street / Pine Street (+83.7).

Seattle Eating / Drinking time series
Eating / Drinking corridor time series.
Seattle Eating / Drinking delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Retail

Top retail corridor change: Broadway (+1.8).

Seattle Retail time series
Retail corridor time series.
Seattle Retail delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Grocery

Top grocery corridor change: Pike Street / Pine Street (+0.9).

Seattle Grocery time series
Grocery corridor time series.
Seattle Grocery delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience

Top liquor / tobacco / convenience corridor change: 1st Avenue / 2nd Avenue (+5.3).

Seattle Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience time series
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience corridor time series.
Seattle Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Personal Care / Laundromats

Top personal care / laundromats corridor change: 1st Avenue / 2nd Avenue (+5.5).

Seattle Personal Care / Laundromats time series
Personal Care / Laundromats corridor time series.
Seattle Personal Care / Laundromats delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Recreation

Top recreation corridor change: 1st Avenue / 2nd Avenue (+0.0).

Seattle Recreation time series
Recreation corridor time series.
Seattle Recreation delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Dollar Stores

Top dollar stores corridor change: Cherry Street / Jackson Street (+0.2).

Seattle Dollar Stores time series
Dollar Stores corridor time series.
Seattle Dollar Stores delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.

Charlotte

North Carolina · Large group

Partial / Limited Removal Date not pinned in local citywide file
Eating / Drinking

Top eating / drinking corridor change: Tryon Street (+49.7).

Charlotte Eating / Drinking time series
Eating / Drinking corridor time series.
Charlotte Eating / Drinking delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Retail

Top retail corridor change: Tryon Street (+6.3).

Charlotte Retail time series
Retail corridor time series.
Charlotte Retail delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Grocery

Top grocery corridor change: Tryon Street (+3.5).

Charlotte Grocery time series
Grocery corridor time series.
Charlotte Grocery delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience

Top liquor / tobacco / convenience corridor change: Tryon Street (+2.2).

Charlotte Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience time series
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience corridor time series.
Charlotte Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Personal Care / Laundromats

Top personal care / laundromats corridor change: Tryon Street (+13.4).

Charlotte Personal Care / Laundromats time series
Personal Care / Laundromats corridor time series.
Charlotte Personal Care / Laundromats delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Recreation

Top recreation corridor change: Boulevard (+0.0).

Charlotte Recreation time series
Recreation corridor time series.
Charlotte Recreation delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Dollar Stores

Top dollar stores corridor change: Boulevard (+0.7).

Charlotte Dollar Stores time series
Dollar Stores corridor time series.
Charlotte Dollar Stores delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.

Denver

Colorado · Large group

Full Removal 2025-08-05
Eating / Drinking

Top eating / drinking corridor change: Broadway / Lincoln Street (+75.0).

Denver Eating / Drinking time series
Eating / Drinking corridor time series.
Denver Eating / Drinking delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Retail

Top retail corridor change: Broadway (+6.1).

Denver Retail time series
Retail corridor time series.
Denver Retail delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Grocery

Top grocery corridor change: Broadway / Lincoln Street (+3.1).

Denver Grocery time series
Grocery corridor time series.
Denver Grocery delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience

Top liquor / tobacco / convenience corridor change: Broadway / Lincoln Street (+17.8).

Denver Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience time series
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience corridor time series.
Denver Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Personal Care / Laundromats

Top personal care / laundromats corridor change: Broadway / Lincoln Street (+15.0).

Denver Personal Care / Laundromats time series
Personal Care / Laundromats corridor time series.
Denver Personal Care / Laundromats delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Recreation

Top recreation corridor change: 16th Street (+0.0).

Denver Recreation time series
Recreation corridor time series.
Denver Recreation delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Dollar Stores

Top dollar stores corridor change: Colfax Avenue (+0.4).

Denver Dollar Stores time series
Dollar Stores corridor time series.
Denver Dollar Stores delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.

Mid Cities

4 shortlisted cities.

Buffalo

New York · Mid group

Full Removal 2017-01-03
Eating / Drinking

Top eating / drinking corridor change: Delaware Avenue (+13.1).

Buffalo Eating / Drinking time series
Eating / Drinking corridor time series.
Buffalo Eating / Drinking delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Retail

Top retail corridor change: Hertel Avenue (+2.0).

Buffalo Retail time series
Retail corridor time series.
Buffalo Retail normalized time series
Normalized against first year, with citywide baseline.
Buffalo Retail delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Grocery

Top grocery corridor change: Bailey Avenue (+0.2).

Buffalo Grocery time series
Grocery corridor time series.
Buffalo Grocery delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience

Top liquor / tobacco / convenience corridor change: Niagara Street (+2.4).

Buffalo Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience time series
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience corridor time series.
Buffalo Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Personal Care / Laundromats

Top personal care / laundromats corridor change: Delaware Avenue (+3.8).

Buffalo Personal Care / Laundromats time series
Personal Care / Laundromats corridor time series.
Buffalo Personal Care / Laundromats delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Recreation

Top recreation corridor change: Bailey Avenue (+0.0).

Buffalo Recreation time series
Recreation corridor time series.
Buffalo Recreation delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Dollar Stores

Top dollar stores corridor change: Delaware Avenue (+1.0).

Buffalo Dollar Stores time series
Dollar Stores corridor time series.
Buffalo Dollar Stores delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.

Richmond

Virginia · Mid group

Full Removal 2023-04-24
Eating / Drinking

Top eating / drinking corridor change: Cary Street (+47.0).

Richmond Eating / Drinking time series
Eating / Drinking corridor time series.
Richmond Eating / Drinking delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Retail

Top retail corridor change: Hull Street (+1.4).

Richmond Retail time series
Retail corridor time series.
Richmond Retail delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Grocery

Top grocery corridor change: Cary Street (+1.0).

Richmond Grocery time series
Grocery corridor time series.
Richmond Grocery delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience

Top liquor / tobacco / convenience corridor change: Cary Street (+4.3).

Richmond Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience time series
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience corridor time series.
Richmond Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Personal Care / Laundromats

Top personal care / laundromats corridor change: Main Street (+2.5).

Richmond Personal Care / Laundromats time series
Personal Care / Laundromats corridor time series.
Richmond Personal Care / Laundromats delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Recreation

Top recreation corridor change: Broad Street (+0.0).

Richmond Recreation time series
Recreation corridor time series.
Richmond Recreation delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Dollar Stores

Top dollar stores corridor change: Hull Street (+0.4).

Richmond Dollar Stores time series
Dollar Stores corridor time series.
Richmond Dollar Stores delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.

Madison

Wisconsin · Mid group

Partial / Limited Removal Date not pinned in local citywide file
Eating / Drinking

Top eating / drinking corridor change: Johnson Street / East Gorham Street (+34.5).

Madison Eating / Drinking time series
Eating / Drinking corridor time series.
Madison Eating / Drinking delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Retail

Top retail corridor change: Mineral Point Road (+2.0).

Madison Retail time series
Retail corridor time series.
Madison Retail delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Grocery

Top grocery corridor change: Washington Avenue (+0.9).

Madison Grocery time series
Grocery corridor time series.
Madison Grocery delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience

Top liquor / tobacco / convenience corridor change: Washington Avenue (+0.3).

Madison Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience time series
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience corridor time series.
Madison Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Personal Care / Laundromats

Top personal care / laundromats corridor change: Mineral Point Road (+3.7).

Madison Personal Care / Laundromats time series
Personal Care / Laundromats corridor time series.
Madison Personal Care / Laundromats delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Recreation

Top recreation corridor change: Atwood Avenue (+0.0).

Madison Recreation time series
Recreation corridor time series.
Madison Recreation delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Dollar Stores

Top dollar stores corridor change: Johnson Street / East Gorham Street (+0.7).

Madison Dollar Stores time series
Dollar Stores corridor time series.
Madison Dollar Stores delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.

Pittsburgh

Pennsylvania · Mid group

Proposal Only Date not pinned in local citywide file
Eating / Drinking

Top eating / drinking corridor change: Liberty Avenue / Penn Avenue (+57.5).

Pittsburgh Eating / Drinking time series
Eating / Drinking corridor time series.
Pittsburgh Eating / Drinking delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Retail

Top retail corridor change: Liberty Avenue / Penn Avenue (+4.7).

Pittsburgh Retail time series
Retail corridor time series.
Pittsburgh Retail delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Grocery

Top grocery corridor change: Liberty Avenue / Penn Avenue (+3.9).

Pittsburgh Grocery time series
Grocery corridor time series.
Pittsburgh Grocery delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience

Top liquor / tobacco / convenience corridor change: Liberty Avenue / Penn Avenue (+8.0).

Pittsburgh Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience time series
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience corridor time series.
Pittsburgh Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Personal Care / Laundromats

Top personal care / laundromats corridor change: Ellsworth Avenue (+4.9).

Pittsburgh Personal Care / Laundromats time series
Personal Care / Laundromats corridor time series.
Pittsburgh Personal Care / Laundromats delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Recreation

Top recreation corridor change: Brighton Road (+0.0).

Pittsburgh Recreation time series
Recreation corridor time series.
Pittsburgh Recreation delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Dollar Stores

Top dollar stores corridor change: Liberty Avenue / Penn Avenue (+1.4).

Pittsburgh Dollar Stores time series
Dollar Stores corridor time series.
Pittsburgh Dollar Stores delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.

Small Cities

3 shortlisted cities.

Hartford

Connecticut · Small group

Full Removal 2017-12-01
Eating / Drinking

Top eating / drinking corridor change: Park Street (+7.8).

Hartford Eating / Drinking time series
Eating / Drinking corridor time series.
Hartford Eating / Drinking delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Retail

Top retail corridor change: Blue Hills Avenue (+1.9).

Hartford Retail time series
Retail corridor time series.
Hartford Retail delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Grocery

Top grocery corridor change: Broad Street (+2.4).

Hartford Grocery time series
Grocery corridor time series.
Hartford Grocery delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience

Top liquor / tobacco / convenience corridor change: Broad Street (+1.4).

Hartford Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience time series
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience corridor time series.
Hartford Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Personal Care / Laundromats

Top personal care / laundromats corridor change: Park Street (+3.9).

Hartford Personal Care / Laundromats time series
Personal Care / Laundromats corridor time series.
Hartford Personal Care / Laundromats delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Recreation

Top recreation corridor change: Albany Avenue (+0.0).

Hartford Recreation time series
Recreation corridor time series.
Hartford Recreation delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Dollar Stores

Top dollar stores corridor change: Franklin Avenue (+0.4).

Hartford Dollar Stores time series
Dollar Stores corridor time series.
Hartford Dollar Stores delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.

Ann Arbor

Michigan · Small group

Full Removal 2022-08-15
Eating / Drinking

Top eating / drinking corridor change: Liberty Street (+21.3).

Ann Arbor Eating / Drinking time series
Eating / Drinking corridor time series.
Ann Arbor Eating / Drinking delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Retail

Top retail corridor change: Washtenaw Avenue (+0.9).

Ann Arbor Retail time series
Retail corridor time series.
Ann Arbor Retail delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Grocery

Top grocery corridor change: Washtenaw Avenue (+0.5).

Ann Arbor Grocery time series
Grocery corridor time series.
Ann Arbor Grocery delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience

Top liquor / tobacco / convenience corridor change: Liberty Street (+1.2).

Ann Arbor Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience time series
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience corridor time series.
Ann Arbor Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Personal Care / Laundromats

Top personal care / laundromats corridor change: Washtenaw Avenue (+0.2).

Ann Arbor Personal Care / Laundromats time series
Personal Care / Laundromats corridor time series.
Ann Arbor Personal Care / Laundromats delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Recreation

Top recreation corridor change: Jackson Avenue (+0.0).

Ann Arbor Recreation time series
Recreation corridor time series.
Ann Arbor Recreation delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Dollar Stores

Top dollar stores corridor change: Jackson Avenue (+0.1).

Ann Arbor Dollar Stores time series
Dollar Stores corridor time series.
Ann Arbor Dollar Stores delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.

New Haven

Connecticut · Small group

Partial / Limited Removal Date not pinned in local citywide file
Eating / Drinking

Top eating / drinking corridor change: Orange Street (+30.3).

New Haven Eating / Drinking time series
Eating / Drinking corridor time series.
New Haven Eating / Drinking delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Retail

Top retail corridor change: Dixwell Avenue (+1.1).

New Haven Retail time series
Retail corridor time series.
New Haven Retail delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Grocery

Top grocery corridor change: York Street / Elm Street (+2.5).

New Haven Grocery time series
Grocery corridor time series.
New Haven Grocery delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience

Top liquor / tobacco / convenience corridor change: Chapel Street (+1.4).

New Haven Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience time series
Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience corridor time series.
New Haven Liquor / Tobacco / Convenience delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Personal Care / Laundromats

Top personal care / laundromats corridor change: Orange Street (+3.3).

New Haven Personal Care / Laundromats time series
Personal Care / Laundromats corridor time series.
New Haven Personal Care / Laundromats delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Recreation

Top recreation corridor change: Broadway (+0.0).

New Haven Recreation time series
Recreation corridor time series.
New Haven Recreation delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.
Dollar Stores

Top dollar stores corridor change: Chapel Street (+0.3).

New Haven Dollar Stores time series
Dollar Stores corridor time series.
New Haven Dollar Stores delta bar chart
First-to-last-year change by corridor.